Act V — Where you fit ·Chapter 14 of 17 ·Interactive ·6 min

Contents

Contents

Fragility or allyship?

New information doesn’t always feel exciting. Sometimes it's overwhelming, enraging, paralyzing — disruptive. Learning doesn’t just add information. Sometimes it asks us to replace false information with the truth. Sometimes it even asks us to then look at other things and do certain things differently as a result.

That can be uncomfortable. It can also be one of the most important parts of growing.

This exhibition has asked readers to look at familiar parts of American history — and of maternal health — from a different perspective. For some people, much of this information will feel familiar. For others, it may challenge stories they’ve always heard about medicine, fairness, opportunity, or the country’s past.

How do we respond to that?

Exhibit · Interactive

Fragility or accountability

Four responses to racial discomfort. Select one to read what it looks like in practice.

These four describe how whiteness meets racial discomfort and accountability. Two are forms of fragility — a feeling, and that feeling turned into a weapon. Two are forms of allyship — one hollow, one real. Tap any one for its telltale signs and the line that separates it from its pair.

When discomfort arises

Select one of the two above to see how it works.

When you try to help

Four related states, easy to confuse. Tap one to see what it looks like — and the exact line that separates it from the one beside it.

Trait lists adapted from a four-part framework by @seerutkchawla

Robin DiAngelo uses the phrase white fragility to describe one response that can happen when conversations about race create discomfort, particularly for white people.

When discomfort becomes the center of the conversation, learning often stops. The discussion shifts away from the people describing harm and toward reassuring the person who feels challenged by hearing about it. Instead of asking, What can I learn from this? the conversation becomes, Please understand that I’m a good person.

Those are very different conversations.

This exhibition isn’t asking anyone to feel personally guilty for history they didn’t create. It’s asking all of us to become more aware of and curious about the systems we inherited, the assumptions we’ve absorbed, and the roles we now play within them. Different things.

That's where allyship begins.

It isn’t a title someone earns or an identity they claim. It’s an ongoing practice of staying open to new information, especially when it challenges something we’ve always believed to be true. Sometimes that means listening more than explaining. Sometimes it means changing our minds. Sometimes it means changing what we do.

Should you get up right now, start doing new stuff, get it all right, and make an immediate positive impact? Not quite. Mistakes will be made. But what are you committed to? How much and in what ways are you willing to engage?

In maternal healthcare, allyship can take many forms along those interpersonal, institutional, and system levels. It may mean believing a patient before asking them to prove their concern. It may mean inviting community members into decisions that have traditionally been made without them. It may mean changing a policy after recognizing that it works well for some families but not for others. It may mean using one’s position to make space for voices that have historically been overlooked.

Yes, most people who enter maternal healthcare want families to be healthy and safe. But dedicating yourself to physical healthcare and actually having a positive impact on the physical health of a patient placed in your care aren't always the same thing. Allyship is measured less by what someone believes about themselves or what they intend to do with their work, and more by what they’re willing to notice, question, change, and support — and what happens to the people they care for as a result.

Get new chapters and updates →

Sources 3 entries

The four states

  • DiAngelo, Robin. “White Fragility.” International Journal of Critical Pedagogy 3, no. 3 (2011): 54–70. Where the phrase is defined.
  • DiAngelo, Robin. White Fragility: Why It’s So Hard for White People to Talk About Racism. Beacon Press, 2018.
  • Trait lists adapted from a four-part framework by Seerut K. Chawla (@seerutkchawla). The lines drawn between the four states, and their application to maternity care, are the exhibition’s own.